General who supported ban on LGBT service members changes mind
WASHINGTON The Army general who was Joint Chiefs chairman when the Pentagon adopted its “Don’t ask, don’t tell” policy on gays says he no longer opposes allowing them to serve openly.
John Shalikashvili, who retired in 1997 after four years as the nation’s top military officer, had argued that allowing gays and lesbians to serve openly would hurt troop morale and recruitment and undermine the cohesion of combat units. He said he has changed his mind after meeting gay servicemen.
“These conversations showed me just how much the military has changed, and that gays and lesbians can be accepted by their peers,” Shalikashvili wrote in an opinion piece published in the New York Times on Tuesday, Jan. 2.
His view could carry weight at a time when advocates of lifting the restriction on gay service members argue that the military under the strain of fighting two wars can ill-afford to exclude any qualified volunteers. It’s not clear, however, how much enthusiasm Congress will have for pressing the matter.
While many Democrats have denounced the policy as discriminatory, many Republicans have supported it. Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., a possible presidential contender in 2008, recently called the military policy “very effective.”
Rep. Marty Meehan on Tuesday hailed Shalikashvili’s article and said he would try this year to revive legislation forcing the military to eliminate the policy. In 2005, Meehan, D-Mass., introduced a similar bill, which eventually attracted 122 co-sponsors, including Republican Chris Shays of Connecticut and Independent Bernard Sanders of Vermont. “There is no place in this country for discrimination, be it on the basis of race, creed or sexual orientation, and there is certainly no place for institutional discrimination codified in federal statute,” Meehan said in a statement.
The current policy, based on legislation passed by Congress in 1993 after a firestorm of debate, states that gays and lesbians may serve in the military only if they keep their sexual orientation private. Commanders may not ask, and gay service members may not tell. Over the years, thousands have been dismissed under this policy.
Shalikashvili, who now lives in Steilacoom, Wash., is not the first former senior military officer to change his mind about gays in the military, though he is perhaps the most prominent.
John Hutson, a retired two-star Navy admiral who was the Navy’s top lawyer, said Tuesday he thinks the nation has undergone so much cultural change over the past decade that allowing gays to serve openly in the military would enhance rather than weaken the cohesion of fighting units. “I think it will absolutely happen,” Hutson said in a telephone interview, “but probably not during the Bush administration.”
Shalikashvili said he expects fierce debate over gays in the military this year as Congress considers President Bush’s call for expanding the size of the Army, which is stretched thin by wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Shalikashvili cautioned against pushing for repeal of the ban early in the new Congress, which he said should be focused on urgent priorities like developing a better strategy in Iraq and healing divisions over the war.
“Fighting early in this Congress to lift the ban on openly gay service members is not likely to add to that healing and it risks alienating people whose support is needed to get this country on the right track,” he wrote in the Times article.
Shalikashvili cited a new Zogby poll, of 545 U.S. troops who served in Iraq and Afghanistan. It reported that three quarters said they were comfortable around gay men and lesbians. The poll also said 37 percent opposed allowing gays to serve openly, while 26 percent said they should be allowed and 37 percent were unsure or neutral.
C. Dixon Osburn, executive director of Servicemembers Legal Defense Network, called the article “enormously significant.” He said it reflects a growing trend of military leaders supporting repeal of the “Don’t ask, don’t tell” policy.
This article appeared in the Dallas Voice print edition, January 5, 2007.