High court may issue 1st Prop 8 ruling this week

U.S. District Judge Vaughn Walker

The Prop 8 case may be going to the Supreme Court sooner than expected — sometime this week.

Not the entire case. Just the motion to extend District Judge Vaughn Walker’s stay.

If the 9th Circuit Court opts not to extend the stay, the defendants in the case may take the case to the Supreme Court.

The argument by anti-gay marriage forces is that the stay needs to be extended to protect those who may marry. If the stay is lifted, those people may suffer harm. Nice of them to be so worried.

According to the New York Times, the anti-marriage folks would be facing an uphill battle on this issue, even with conservative members of the Supreme Court.

First, the interveners who’ve defended Prop 8 in the lower courts would have to convince the high court that this is their battle to fight. The state is the named defendant, but California’s governor and attorney general have declined to defend the marriage ban. In his decision last week allowing the stay to expire this Wednesday afternoon, Judge Walker questioned the defendants’ standing.

In the past, conservative members of the high court have taken narrow views about who has standing in appeals. No matter how much Justices Scalia, Thomas, Roberts and Alito may despise the idea of same-sex marriage, allowing this group to appeal the case when the named defendants have declined to do so would go against precedent.

—  David Taffet

Clearing the confusion on lifting the stay: Walker’s stay order will expire as originally scheduled next Wednesday

Ken Upton, senior staff attorney in Lambda Legal’s South Central Regional Office here in Dallas, has cleared up the confusion over Judge Vaughn Walker’s ruling on lifting the stay of his order overturning Proposition 8.

Upton explains, in a comment to an earlier Instant Tea post, that Walker has declined to extend the stay he issued last week, but instead to let it expire as originally scheduled on Wednesday, Aug. 18, at 5 p.m. PST.

The 9th Circuit Court of Appeals has the option to issue its own stay of Walker’s ruling against Prop 8. I have heard a rumor that I can’t even begin to confirm yet that the 9th Circuit isn’t likely to issue a stay. If that is how it turns out, same-sex couples will again be able to legally marry in California beginning next Wednesday.

The question still remains as to whether the Yes on 8 campaign — which unsuccessfully defended Prop 8 in Walker’s court — even as legal standing to appeal Walker’s ruling. The actual defendants in the case were Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and Attorney General Jerry Brown, both of whom declined to defend the amendment and both of whom issued statements this week saying same-sex couples should be allowed to legally marry. Since the Yes on 8 people are actually only “defendant intervenors,” they might not have legal standing to appeal Walker’s decision, some experts have said.

—  admin