She’s conquered comedy. Now Melissa McCarthy is bringing queer forger Lee Israel to (dramatic) life
Melissa McCarthy knows her way around women who don’t care what other people think. This is the foundation on which her bawdy and vanity-free slapstick characters have been created, from her anti-feminine hornball Megan in Bridesmaids (which earned her an Oscar nomination) to gun-toting ballbuster Officer Mullins in The Heat, McCarthy’s daring approach to all-out characters has made her a hero to audiences and critics.
If you’ve ever gotten a lesbian read on McCarthy’s subversive heroines, you’re not misreading… exactly. The 48-year-old actress (and bona fide action star) says the characteristics of being lesbian — not caring, disregard for convention, sensible shoes — are absolutely at play in her work.
There’s nothing vague about Lee Israel’s sexuality in McCarthy’s latest film — the poignant, Oscar-worthy dramedy Can You Ever Forgive Me? — but even if you didn’t know her as a real-life literary scammer (she forged and sold letters by famous writers like Noël Coward and Dorothy Parker), McCarthy will make you care deeply about this woman who, in true McCarthy fashion, has few cares herself.
Recently, McCarthy talked about steeping her onscreen personas in lesbian qualities “out of admiration,” her appreciation for queer films wherein a character’s sexuality is not the whole story and why her drag alias is “Miss Y.”
— Chris Azzopardi
Dallas Voice: What took you so long to play a lesbian character that went beyond being just suggestively lesbian? Melissa McCarthy: [Laughs] It hadn’t been presented to me. I just fell in love with Lee. I was not even a quarter of the way through the script and I thought, “My god, she’s so unapologetic about who she is and how her demeanor is.” I tend to always fall in love with women who simply don’t care what other people think of them — sometimes to their detriment. I don’t think it made her life easier that she was so prickly with so many people, to say the least. But I think in a world where so many people look outward to see, “How do you think I am?” as opposed to, “I know who I am, I know how I am, and I’m fine with it,” there was something in Lee’s voice that really appealed to me. I thought a little bit more of Lee in all of us would not be a bad thing.
Was there something special that stood out to you about the film’s treatment of her sexuality? Yeah, I liked that it wasn’t treated as if her sexuality was something new — a new sweater she got, or something she was trying on. I would say 80 percent of my friends are gay and it’s not something that is an integral part of who they are — it’s not an accessory or a phase — and I thought it was just simply sunk into who she was as a woman, and I related to that. That seemed real to me, and it’s about time that’s the type of character you see: where it’s part of the whole person, and it doesn’t always lead with it.
Eighty percent is very precise. Has it always been 80 percent? Probably! I mean, still to this day, I don’t know why. Who knows how and why and who you pick as your friends, but it’s usually me and all my lovely, dear gay friends that I’ve had forever.
In the film, Richard E. Grant portrays Jack Hock, a charming gay boozer who becomes Lee’s drinking buddy and partner in crime. Do you have a gay friend as close to you as Lee Israel was to Jack? I have about five of them. They were all my bridesmen. I had my sister — and then I had five bridesmen.
Did you make some new gay friends while shooting at New York City’s oldest gay bar, Julius’? I didn’t meet anyone new in there, but I found it fascinating that that’s where Lee hung out. I thought that was very telling of her not wanting to be seen, but to still be with people who wouldn’t judge her, especially in the early ’90s. But no, no new friends! Richard’s my new friend!
Richard as Jack is everyone’s new gay friend. Isn’t he? I think it took me three seconds to literally fall in love with him. I was just like, “Oh my god, where have you been all my life?” I think how he played Jack and how bigger-than-life he was, and then how vulnerable and how he could break your heart — I just can’t imagine anyone else on the planet playing Jack. I thought Richard was perfect.
How did Lee’s friendship with Jack — two gay people living during the AIDS crisis — speak to you? I thought what really tethered the whole story were these two characters. These people are so lonely, so isolated, desperate in different ways but similar in others. Who hasn’t had that feeling? Who hasn’t felt completely alone or undervalued? And to put that in this time period, I mean, that’s part of why I’m so fascinated. When I found out she hung out at Julius’, especially in the early ’90s, I thought she wouldn’t meet anyone there. Then I thought, “Of course!” And she knew that. So she would go to just be isolated, and I thought, “Oh, Lee.” I just sometimes rooted for her. I know it’s crazy, but the scene with Dolly Wells, who plays Anna so brilliantly… and I know how this movie ends; I’ve seen it, I did it. And yet every time right before Lee makes that turn outside the restaurant, I can’t help but go, “Oh, please, let it work out.” She’s so close to having a lovely thing, and then Lee kind of could not get out of her own way.
The LGBTQ community has seemingly found lesbian subtext in some of your characters. Did you recognize the lesbian sensibility when you shot The Heat with Sandra Bullock as much as gay critics did? It wasn’t intentionally driven by that, but it was driven by a sense of, I don’t have to be anyone else than I am. I’ve had and still have so many great lesbian friends. I remember early on just being like, “Boy, they’re just not putting on these airs and stereotypes of what it means to be a woman, and they certainly seem comfortable and at ease with it,” and there was a real weighted feeling to that. I remember being like, “Yeah, why am I in a heel? What am I doing?” Like, “This seems dumb. She’s not in one and between the two of us that’s the smarter move.” I just remember thinking someone who stops doing certain social cues that have been assigned and simply does what they want is very appealing to me. I find it very strong and respect it quite a bit.
So many of the women I play when I do play these characters — because I love them, I love them because they’re too aggressive, too whatever it is — but I love that they’re really in their shoes and some of those great women I’ve known over the years always carry into them because I think, “Don’t mess with her because she knows exactly who she is and she’s standing solid.” I love the fact that they’ve crept in. You know, it’s out of admiration.
These characters you play are a real subversion of conventional gender norms. Yeah, that “who’s to say what” — I do love playing with that. It’s like, you don’t know anyone’s story. You can’t go off a look or a feeling; you don’t know until you know. And maybe it’ll never be any of your business.
The lesbian chemistry between Sandra Oh and Kathy Bates in your film Tammy — you called it “magical.” If you were to play another lesbian role after Lee, who would you want your love interest to be? That’s a tough question! That’s like, “What’s your favorite album?” I don’t know! Oh, god. Glenn Close, I don’t know. There are so many women that I love, that I find magical, I couldn’t possibly answer that. It would be endless.
As a kid who grew up on a farm, where I imagine there weren’t a lot of out and loud farmers... Not many that I knew of!
… What was your experience the first time you stepped into a gay bar, then? I thought, “Where has this been all my life?” That’s the honest to god truth. There was a feeling of anything goes, you’re OK, no one’s gonna find you odd. What you’re wearing, who cares! What you’re doing, dancing all night! There just was a celebration innately built in. It’s like, I didn’t go there to be somber, I went because I was like, there’s such a feeling of unity and I never felt… I just… I really did, I had such a strong reaction to it. It’s like, I think, certainly, from many of my friends I was with as they came out and struggled with their families or had delightfully surprising responses from their family, to have a place to go where they were just fully accepted, a lot of joy went with that. So I kind of sat in the backdrop of that and enjoyed it.
The feeling must’ve been so strong that “Miss Y” was born. How did you get your drag name? [Laughs] I do kind of consider it my drag name. I was given it by a lesbian in southern Illinois. When I went to college, I went by Melissa, but up until college I had always been called “Missy.” And someone who knew me before said, “Missy,” in front of this woman and she went, “Uh! My friend ‘Missy’? Completely unacceptable! I’ll call you ‘Miss Y.’” I don’t know why she was really offended by Missy, but bizarrely it stuck and everyone called me Miss Y. When I ended up in New York, it had become somewhat of an alter ego… and in my wig and silver lamé trench coat dress, Miss Y was born.
Which drag look was physically easier to transform into: Miss Y or Divine, who you impersonated for an Entertainment Weekly cover shoot — or Sean Spicer? Sadly, Sean Spicer was quicker. I was like, “This will take hours,” and they’re like, “Not really. It’ll take about 17 minutes,” and I was like, “Oh, come on!” I would’ve loved for them to have been like, “Oh, it’s really difficult to make her that masculine.” Instead, nope. Really easy. I had no problem doing it!
What do your daughters think of Miss Y? They don’t really know her — thank god they were not at the Palladium [a NYC gay bar] in ’92 with me!
Wait, what happened at the Palladium in ’92? Oh, so many things. So many things that I’ll never put on a recorder. Susanne Bartsch parties and debauchery; the ball pit, the slide. I could go on but I won’t!
You know, one day they’re gonna ask about went happened with Miss Y in ’92 at that bar. You know, something I hope my girls feel is a freedom. I always say I find them delightfully weird, which I have always rooted for. We play a strange game that is not really meant to offend any banker, we just mean this as a generalization, which is terrible — but we play a weird game where we’re a very serious family and Ben [Falcone, McCarthy’s husband] will come out and say, “Hello, children, how was education?” And they answer very properly and we can only do it for about a minute and a half. It’s really weird and then we all feel uncomfortable and a weird dance party starts. So I love that they fully embrace that they can be as strange and goofy as they want to be. I think that’s a feather in my cap, that they’re not afraid to be exactly who they are.
Do pieces of Miss Y exist in any of the characters you play? I think there’s always a bit of her. Not surprisingly, the beginning of me being a character actress — I didn’t even do stand-up for that long. I couldn’t possibly do it as myself. It didn’t make any sense to me. But I could go on as her and tell amazing stories about myself and talk about being so young and wealthy and tall and all these things that I was not. And I could kind of channel it through someone and do that without any reservations or embarrassment. I think I’ve taken that into so many of these flawed, challenging women that I play. As long as I can channel through someone else, I feel quite a bit braver.